Shiba Inu’s “Shibarium” is new dog learning new tricks
Aug. 23, 2023
Exploring the tech behind crypto
one block at a time
Was this newsletter forwarded to you?Sign up here.
Hi, Bradley Keoun here, editor of The Protocol.
A lot of the buzz in blockchain tech circles this year has been over the push toward secondary “layer-2” networks atop Ethereum being built on “zero-knowledge” cryptography, or ZK – seen by many experts as superior to the “optimistic rollups” that currently dominate. So the question is why the U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase and venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz are choosing OP Stack, modeled after Optimism’s optimistic rollup, to build their new networks. Margaux Nijkerk dives into the question in this week’s feature.
Also this week:
How the arrival of a viral crypto-fueled social marketplace called Friend.tech has quickly energized Coinbase’s new Base blockchain.
Shiba Inu community’s “Shibarium” blockchain aims for restart after troubled debut.
Coinbase’s ‘Optimistic’ Blockchain Sees Zero Threat from ZK Proofs
Optimism CEO Karl Floersch (Optimism)
In recent months, there’s been a clear trend among big crypto-focused firms – including Coinbase, Binance, and Andreessen Horowitz (a16z) – looking to start their own “layer-2” blockchain solutions atop Ethereum: They’ve chosen OP Stack, from the team that created Optimism, to provide the open-source software building blocks for their new networks.
On the surface, it might seem like a surprising pattern, since many top Ethereum aficionados have predicted that the most promising layer-2 blockchains would be built not using the OP Stack’s “optimistic rollup” technology but with a fundamentally different setup known as “ZK rollups,” powered by zero-knowledge cryptography. A key difference is the speed of finalizing transactions: With ZK rollups, it’s almost instantaneous, whereas with optimistic rollups, the process can take minutes or even days.
This dissonance – between the recent commercial track record and the widely held vision for the future – raises the question of whether OP Stack is merely an interim solution for companies that want to start their own layer-2 blockchains now, hinging on the assumption that eventually the industry will pivot toward ZK technology. Or maybe there’s a flaw in the common wisdom that ZK tech will eventually dominate?
The short answer might be that ZK rollups are still seen as the best solution for scaling Ethereum, in the long run.
“I’d say they choose the OP stack because it is easy to spin it up and there is no need to arrange a hardcore ZK team for this,” said Mikhail Komarov, CEO of Nil Foundation, a research and development firm designed to expand the reach of ZK technology and adoption. “Once there is an easy way to spin-up ZK-rollup stack, they will migrate to that.”
What’s less understood, perhaps, at least according to the Optimism team, is that the OP Stack will eventually allow builders the flexibility to pick and choose between various attributes. Those include whether to adopt proofs used with ZK rollup technology instead of implementing optimistic fraud proofs.
Chart shows surge in buyers on Base’s Friend.tech app after the project announced it had received an investment earlier this year from the crypto-focused venture capital firm Paradigm. (Messari/Dune)
PRICE OF POPULARITY: Coinbase, the big U.S. crypto exchange, is getting a fast education, as one of the first big publicly traded companies to run its own blockchain. Its new Base project, a layer-2 network atop Ethereum, just launched this month, and already one of its new applications, Friend.tech, has gone viral, quickly attracting more than 100,000 users and generating more than $25 million in fees. Friend.tech, which allows users to purchase shares of X (Twitter) influencers, saw a rapid spike in activity (see chart above) after announcing on Aug. 18 that it had scored seed funding earlier this year from the crypto-focused venture-capital firm Paradigm. Friend.tech’s early success has helped drive up key metrics on the Base network, driving its total value locked (TVL) past $200 million and at one point pushing transactions per second above those of Ethereum as well as rival layer-2 projects Arbitrum and Optimism. According to FundStrat, Base has accrued nearly $4 million in fees, $2.5 million of which is retained by Coinbase; it works out to $30 million extra revenue on an annual basis. One question is whether Base can retain the growth once this hot ball of money bounces to the next crypto craze. “Friend.Tech’s speculative nature,” writes Galaxy Research, “highlights ongoing questions over Coinbase’s role in moderating a chain that today is ‘decentralized’ in name only.”
TAKING PROFITS? Blockchain data shows that Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin withdrew 1,000 ether (ETH) (worth $1.67 million) from the DeFi lender Maker and then deposited 600 ETH ($1 million) on Coinbase, the crypto exchange, according to the X account @Lookonchain. It’s not clear why Buterin transferred the ether, but typically such moves are seen by analysts as a precursor to a sale. The price of ETH is up 39% year-to-date, after a recent market slide. According to CryptoSlate, “the wallet known as “vitalik.eth” was created seven years ago and contained 3,993 ETH (worth $6.5 million) as of press time.”
BINANCE BLUES. The world’s largest crypto exchangesowed confusion after mistakenly announcing on social media that euro transactions were no longer available. Its banking partner in Europe, Paysafe Payment Solutions, subsequently cleared up that withdrawals and deposits would still be available until Sept. 25. But Binance has not provided a timeframe for what happens after that. The exchange faces investigations and regulatory suits in several jurisdictions, including France and the U.S. Separately, Binance.US struck a deal with the payment startup MoonPay to restore customers’ ability to deposit dollars, suspended in June after the company lost ties with various banking partners.
Also:
Tornado Cash developers Roman Storm and Roman Semenov were arrested and charged with money laundering and sanctions violations tied to their work with the privacy mixer, which allegedly “facilitated more than $1 billion in money laundering” for North Korea’s Lazarus Group.
An El Savadoran entrepreneur hasinvented a $1,200 Lightning Network-enabled ATM that reduces costs of fiat-to-bitcoin conversions compared with other Bitcoin on-ramps.
Highlighting blockchain tech upgrades and developments.
StarkWare co-founders CEO Uri Kolodny and President Eli Ben-Sasson (Natalie Schor/StarkWare)
Starkware, Israeli company behind Ethereum layer 2 blockchain StarkNet, said in a press release that they would be open-sourcing their cryptographic software tool, STARK Prover, which has been renamed Stone, on Aug. 31.
Shibarium, new layer-2 blockchain atop Ethereum for Shiba Inu community and its SHIB coin, plans to reopen the network after its much-hyped launch was marred by network issues and a faulty bridge.
Maple Finance, a crypto credit marketplace, is returning to Solana after suspending all lending pools in January following the collapse of Sam Bankman-Fried’s FTX exchange.
WhiteBIT, a Ukrainian crypto exchange, announced the launch of WB Network, an Ethereum-compatible blockchain.
Want to showcase your project’s latest development?
Coinbase agreed to acquire a minority stake in Circle Internet Financial, which will bring issuance and governance of the popular USDC stablecoin fully in-house. Previously, the stablecoin was issued by a consortium of the two companies, called Centre, which will now be dissolved.
Stellar Development Foundation has joinedBytecode Alliance, a nonprofit focused on advancing WebAssembly (Wasm), a “software format from Web2 that functions well with multiple coding languages,” characterized as an “alternative to Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM) for smart contracts,” according to a statement from the team.
Data and tokens
Near Protocol’s native token NEAR jumped in price after an announcement that the network was integrated into the crypto exchange Nexo.
Balancer, one of Ethereum’s top decentralized crypto trading projects, saw its total value locked (TVL) – the amount of deposits on the protocol – fall by $100 million, after disclosing the existence of a critical vulnerability and urging some customers to withdraw their tokens. On Wednesday, the project posted on X that “over 97% of liquidity initially deemed vulnerable is now SAFE,” but $5.6 million “remains at risk.”
Terra, the layer 1 blockchain at the center of 2022’s crypto downturn following the collapse of its native algorithmic stablecoin, LUNA, said its website was compromised over the weekend by hackers attempting phishing attacks on visitors.
Solana – one of the hardest hit blockchain projects in 2022 partly due to its reputation as one of the “Sam coins” with ties to Sam Bankman-Fried’s trading firm, not to mention the revelation by CoinDesk that much of the activity in the ecosystem was faked – might have regained some of its footing. According to a recent report from the analysis firm Delphi Digital, Solana’s “developer ecosystem has consolidated but remained resilient, and the core protocol has shipped meaningful code.” This year, Solana’s total value locked (TVL) has jumped 96%, according to the report, with improving prospects for fast adoption of applications built on the network.
Last week’s feature in The Protocol, by Sage D. Young and yours truly, highlighted the growing conversations over EigenLayer, a project focused on “restaking” – essentially a way of repurposing ether (ETH) staked on Ethereum’s proof-of-stake network to secure additional projects. The story noted that EigenLayer keeps raising its capacity, and the limits keep getting maxxed out immediately – seen as a sign of demand (or at least speculation). The story noted that another capacity increase was due on Aug. 22. Well, that happened, and the project immediately hit the new caps, as reported Wednesday by our Oliver Knight.
Calendar
Aug. 24-27: BitBlockBoom conference, Austin, Texas.
