Let’s Talk About Crypto Protocol Layers and Why Investors Must Examine Them
Finding new and profitable investment ideas is the unending task facing any investor or allocator of capital. While bitcoin (BTC) and ether (ETH) dominate the discussion around cryptocurrencies, the opportunity set for investors expands well beyond.
Some of those candidates are, however, intrinsically tied to the Bitcoin and Ethereum blockchains, borne out of the need to enhance their capabilities. Bitcoin and Ethereum are known as layer 1 (L1) protocols, and these attempts to scale and expand them are called layer 2s (L2).
An L1’s value stems from “blockspace,” territory on a blockchain where information or a smart contract lives. BTC, ETH and tokens for other L1s are valued based on demand for that. They are, so to speak, the tickets to a dance and cost more when more people want to attend; one reason to buy is because you expect higher prices later due to people scrambling to get in the door.
Bitcoin lets people engage in peer-to-peer transactions; the price of BTC rises with demand for that. Ethereum and similar L1 protocols grant people access to smart contracts, decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols and, eventually, stuff we can’t currently envision; ETH and its peers ride along with that.
But blockspace is scarce. And Ethereum, the biggest smart contract-based layer 1, cannot handle anything close to the volume seen elsewhere in finance. It can process a few dozen transactions per second, trailing the Visa network or New York Stock Exchange by several orders of magnitude – a big obstacle to decentralized finance (DeFi) taking over traditional finance tasks.
So, if a layer 1 protocol is a room people are rushing to get into, imagine a long line at the door and skyrocketing price of admission. That’s where layer 2s come in. They act like an overflow room at a convention. If you can’t get into the main auditorium to see the hot keynote speaker, you can get into a side room with a TV screen showing their speech and meet with other attendees.
An L2 is similar. It is a place where transactions can be offloaded from the L1 for faster and/or cheaper processing, but the trades are intrinsically linked to and can be fed back into the L1. If an L1 is a room people want to get into, L2s represent the construction of new ways to get inside, allowing broader access and reducing congestion.
For Ethereum, well-known layer 2 protocols include Polygon, Arbitrum and Optimism. For Bitcoin, there’s Stacks.
Like their L1 counterparts, L2 protocols generally have their own native token, which serves as an incentive to use the network. As an investor, I view a layer 2 as an investment in the infrastructure that allows greater access to the main room, while providing space for developers to build new and useful things. And so even if I don’t know what those useful things are yet, I know that more levels and doorways are needed in the building itself. Knowing that, I want to invest in the materials that will provide the new infrastructure.
Let’s examine a few:
Polygon is the first layer 2 platform that comes to mind for most. Acting as a scaling system, the platform lets developers build decentralized applications on Ethereum. It’s much faster, capable of about 65,000 transactions per second versus 30 on Ethereum. JPMorgan generated buzz last year by doing a DeFi trade using Polygon. Its native token, MATIC, currently has a $9.8 billion market capitalization and revenue of $47 million. Year to date, MATIC is up 48%.
Immutable X operates as a scaling system for non-fungible tokens (NFT), aiming to address high gas fees and slow processing times. Its native token, IMX, lags behind MATIC in market capitalization at $880 million. The dispersion between the two highlights both MATIC’s significant market share and the potential opportunity for the tokens that fall behind it. Year to date, IMX is up 173%.
Stacks has made quite a splash in the past month or so. While Polygon and Immutable X help Ethereum scale, it is focused on Bitcoin, where it has enabled NFTs known as Ordinals. Stacks has expanded Bitcoin beyond just peer-to-peer transactions, which has, for good reason, caught the eye of the crypto community. Its native token, STX, leads all crypto assets with market caps in excess of $1 billion in year-to-date performance (up 254%).
The success or failure of these projects will be determined over time, but the impact, opportunity and access they provide should be on everyone’s mind.
Cboe Digital is a U.S. regulated exchange and clearinghouse bringing trust and transparency to the crypto spot and derivatives markets. Cboe Digital honors a separation of duties and includes intermediaries as a key tenet in managing risk and avoiding conflicts of interest. Our unified spot and derivatives markets are underpinned by responsible innovation and enable collateral efficiency. www.cboedigital.com.
Institutional Outlook
Crypto Rails Should Bring Efficiency Gains to the $7T-a-Day TradFi FX Market
Crypto prices are wobbling amid Silvergate Bank’s woes and the U.S. government’s regulation-by-enforcement campaign. But I’m looking past that, thinking about the likely future collision of crypto and the legacy plumbing of finance and markets. How will they interact? What efficiencies will result from deploying the best of both worlds? What happens to existing over-the-counter and private markets? What real-world assets will shift to on-chain trading?
The authors studied the first six months of trading on a Uniswap liquidity pool that contains USD coin (USDC) and euro coin (EUROC). (It launched in July.) More than $120 million traded through the automated market maker (AMM), which provided liquidity 24/7 without a hiccup during the depths of crypto winter.
The Uniswap EUROC / USDC liquidity pool on March 5. (Uniswap)
Sure, there’s only $1.32 million in total value locked (TVL). But something significant is afoot here as two fiat-backed stablecoins get swapped efficiently and without fanfare on chain.
The traditional currency market is something like a $7-trillion-a-day, mostly over-the-counter business. It’s opaque and complex. There’s no official prices. And an estimated one-third of all volume (about $2 trillion daily) has settlement risk, according to a 2022 Bank for International Settlements survey.
Meanwhile, this USDC/EUROC pool completed transactions on a public ledger, and did it really efficiently. During the study period, prices stuck within a few basis points of the conventional EUR/USD exchange rate. There was weekend liquidity, a time when the traditional FX spot market goes dark. And there were fewer intermediaries and their associated fees and frictions. Automation worked.
“DeFi can reduce remittance costs by as much as 80 percent relative to banks and money transmitters relying on traditional payment systems,” the study authors wrote. That amounts to “a gain of around $30 billion per year going to households” most reliant on remittance payments from families across borders, they added.
While a lowly USDC/EUROC stablecoin liquidity pool might seem like a rather mundane example of crypto in action, it points to the numerous benefits, increased efficiencies of a blockchain future. Don’t overlook that amid the day-to-day of crypto price action.
– Todd Groth, CFA, head of index research at CoinDesk Indices
Takeaways
From CoinDesk’s Nick Baker, here’s some recent news worth reading:
SILVERGATE SAGA: New week, new source of trouble. Crypto bank Silvergate said it’s on shaky financial footing by giving the dreaded “going concern” warning. But something else it did might matter more to the institutional community: It closed the Silvergate Exchange Network (SEN), a platform that helped traditional finance (TradFi) players tie into crypto exchanges. It was a “24/7 instant settlement service the bank’s clients could use to conduct transactions between each other at any time, including nights and weekends,” according to a recent CoinDesk story. It was an important service given so much of TradFi is not 24/7; this was a vital bridge. Signature Bank’s Signet is an alternative, though, and BCB Group is rushing to add features to help fill the gap.
COURT BOMBSHELL: Courtrooms generally aren’t as exciting as they’re portrayed in movies and on TV. But the Voyager Digital bankruptcy case got spicy last week when a U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission official said agency staff believe Binance.US is an unregistered securities exchange. While the SEC’s five commissioners would have to back that statement for it to have any teeth, in the dense thicket of Washington regulation-ese this counts as high drama and a big allegation.
ANOTHER BOMBSHELL: SEC Chair Gary Gensler rejected the idea that exchanges could be safe custodians of crypto assets. “Based upon how crypto trading and lending platforms generally operate, investment advisers cannot rely on them today as qualified custodians,” he said at a recent meeting. “To be clear: Just because a crypto trading platform claims to be a qualified custodian doesn’t mean that it is.” The government crypto crackdown is getting real, real fast.
COINBASE DEAL: Coinbase has acquired One River Digital Asset Management, an institutional crypto asset manager and SEC-registered investment adviser. This is approximately item number 19,362 on the list of examples over the years of TradFi and crypto intersecting (or trying to), but arguably one of the bigger ones. What Coinbase bought is an onramp for conventional finance players to get into crypto. Conventional finance players actually getting into crypto in a big way remains the elusive Holy Grail, but Coinbase is positioning itself for if/when that finally happens.
To hear more analysis, click herefor CoinDesk’s “Markets Daily Crypto Roundup” podcast.
Mint your Consensus NFT Pass to lock in a unique and exclusive Consensus experience for the next three years – all for less than the walkup price of one Pro pass ($2,799). Are you ready to own a piece of Consensus history? Start your mint.
